• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Fed and Fulfilled

An always gluten-free, mostly Paleo and AIP food blog.

  • Home
  • About
    • About Fed and Fulfilled
    • Disclosure and Privacy
  • Life and Health
  • Recipe Index
    • AIP
    • Apps and Snacks
    • Breakfast
    • Condiments
    • Drinks
    • Dessert
    • Main Course
    • Salads
    • Sides
  • Shop
  • Resources
  • Contact

AIP “Chocolate” Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo)

December 7, 2017 by Joanna 4 Comments

AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - these soft and chewy cookies taste just like chocolate but are made with carob and frosted with peppermint coconut butter! | fedandfulfilled.comAnother Christmas season is upon us and I’m thrilled to have a new AIP cookie recipe for you to add to your holiday baking list!  Even though this blog is dedicated to all sorts of dishes, I always have a special place in my heart for recipes that involve baking!  And today’s new cookies will have a special place in YOUR heart once you taste them! 🙂

Naturally, as Christmas rolls around each year, I love getting back in the kitchen to make treats of all sort.  And not even the Autoimmune Protocol (AIP) diet can keep me from creating delicious desserts, like today’s AIP “Chocolate” Mint Thumbprint Cookies!  I’m not even a chocolate mint fan,  but these are absolutely incredible.  Especially considering these are chocolate-free (notice the quotations in the title), thanks to AIP-compliant carob powder! The results are amazingly chocolate-like, with a light and refreshing sweetness from the peppermint frosting centers.

So, put on your favorite Christmas music, preheat your oven to 350, and get ready to try these soft, chewy, festive AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint cookies!

AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - thick, chewy carob cookies taste just like chocolate and are filled with a creamy peppermint frosting! Yum! | fedandfulfilled.com
What’s something that makes you joyful at Christmas?

For me, it’s baking.  (Probably doesn’t come as a surprise!)  I love baking throughout the year, but especially around the holidays.  And it’s not only because it’s part of my “job” as a food blogger!  I love baking up new holiday treats and sharing them with loved ones.  I love browsing the beautiful cookie trays at Christmas parties.  I love decorating loads of Christmas cookies to enjoy while watching “It’s a Wonderful Life.”

AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - these allergy-friendly Christmas cookies are SO delicious and are made with AIP-friendly carob powder! | fedandfulfilled.comMost of all, I love how baking evokes so many nostalgic, happy memories of my family.  Particularly, of my Sitto (“grandma” in Arabic) and my mom – the two best bakers I know!  My Sitto was known for her buttery Syrian bread and crispy, sweet baklava, which she always kept on hand for guests, neighbors, and of course, her beloved grandchildren! 🙂

My mom also had a passion for baking, especially at Christmas.  She’d bake dozens of cut-out sugar cookies and patiently assist my brother and me as we drowned them in frosting!  And instead of buying gifts for relatives, church friends, and neighbors, she would bake trays and trays of beautiful and delicious cookies.  From simple peanut blossoms and crackle-top ginger cookies to decadent seven-layer bars and Sitto’s baklava, they would all get wrapped up with colorful ribbons in cute little baskets.AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - thick, chewy carob cookies taste just like chocolate and are filled with a creamy peppermint frosting! Yum! | fedandfulfilled.comAlong with the numerous cookies, my mom would also bake the most incredible cheesecakes!  There was almost always a decadent cheesecake for Christmas dessert to serve our guests. A favorite among them was a rich chocolate mint “Grasshopper” Cheesecake.  As a child, I wanted to like this dreamy chocolate mint dessert, but I could never quite understand the mass appeal!  Even now, I still shy away from the chocolate/mint combo if given the choice.  But, when I was brainstorming ideas for a new AIP cookie recipe, the festive chocolate mint flavors from that Grasshopper Cheesecake came to mind and I knew I had to give it another try!  And wow, I’m really glad I did!

AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - soft, thick carob cookies tastes just like chocolate and are filled with creamy peppermint frosting! | fedandfulfilled.comThese AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies totally exceeded my expectations!  Not only does the carob taste remarkably like chocolate, but the peppermint gives it a powerful punch without overwhelming everything.  I must say, even peppermint itself is really growing on me.  I’ve used peppermint essential oil as a headache cure and sipped peppermint tea often to ease digestive distress.  After adding peppermint into this cookie recipe, I think I finally understand why so many people go crazy for chocolate and mint together!

So, for those who made my Soft and Chewy Gingerbread Cookies last year, you already have an edge on this recipe!  My AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies require similar ingredients – Spectrum organic palm shortening, grass-fed gelatin, coconut flour, and arrowroot starch, with the addition of a few new items, like carob powder, peppermint oil, and my favorite Artisana Coconut Butter.  (If you’re NOT on an AIP diet, feel free to use regular cocoa powder.  Just note that carob is sweeter than cocoa, so you may need to add extra honey or coconut sugar if you make the swap.)

AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - festive chocolate mint cookies are reinvented with the use of carob and coconut butter frosting! | fedandfulfilled.comThe basic method is the same as with my gingerbread cookies and you’ll end up with a soft, moldable dough that doesn’t spread much.  Roll your dough into balls and then flatten slightly and imprint each center of the cookie with your thumb or a small spoon.  You just want enough of an indent to hold the frosting after they bake!

AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - soft carob cookies taste like chocolate and are filled with refreshing peppermint frosting for a delicious combination! | fedandfulfilled.comOnce baked, let your AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies cool off while you mix up the frosting.  One word of caution when making the frosting!  Only use 1-2 drops of peppermint oil to start with.  It’s SUPER concentrated (more than peppermint extract), so if you use too much, it’ll be bitter and overpowering.  If you don’t have food-grade peppermint oil, then simply substitute peppermint extract and about 1/4 teaspoon or so.

AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - soft, chewy carob cookies are filled with a refreshing peppermint frosting for a festive Christmas treat! | fedandfulfilled.comThese AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies sit well at room temperature, but I’d imagine they’d keep beautifully in the freezer if you want to make a batch now and save them for a Christmas cookie exchange!   Try them with a hot cup of peppermint tea or (if you can tolerate coffee) a frothy peppermint mocha.  And don’t forget to share a few with the chocolate mint fans in your life!

If you’re looking for more AIP-friendly cookies to try, check out my Frosted Cut-Out Sugar Cookies and my Paleo Matcha Lime Macaroons!  Don’t be afraid to try new or unique flavors!  Even ones you may not have liked in the past…like chocolate mint! 😉

Whether it’s baking cookies, eating cookies, or something totally non-cookie related, do something that makes you joyful this Christmas!  And one thing we can ALL be joyful for is God’s gracious gift to the world, who was born in Bethlehem many, many years ago.  “Joy to the world, the Lord is come!  Let earth receive her King!”  Wishing you all a wonderful, joyful Christmas season!

AIP Chocolate Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo) - allergy-friendly "chocolate" mint cookies that are perfect for Christmas! | fedandfulfilled.com

5.0 from 1 reviews
AIP "Chocolate" Mint Thumbprint Cookies (Paleo)
 
Print
Created by: Joanna Smith
Serves: 1 dozen
Ingredients
  • ½ cup palm shortening
  • ¼ cup coconut sugar
  • 2 tablespoons raw honey
  • ¼ cup carob powder
  • 1 teaspoon cream of tartar
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 1 gelatin "egg" (1 tablespoon gelatin powder + 4 tablespoons water)
  • 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar
  • ½ cup coconut flour
  • ½ cup arrowroot starch

Peppermint Frosting:
  • 4 tablespoons coconut butter, melted
  • 1-2 drops peppermint oil (food grade)
  • 2 teaspoons raw honey
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees and prepare a baking sheet with parchment paper.
  2. In a stand mixer, cream together the palm shortening, coconut sugar and honey. Add in the carob, cream of tartar, baking soda, and salt and mix.
  3. In a small saucepan, make the gelatin egg by adding 4 tablespoons of water and sprinkling 1 tablespoon of gelatin powder over top. Let sit for a minute, then whisk over low heat until mixture is very foamy.
  4. Pour gelatin mixture into the cookie dough mixture and mix until incorporated.
  5. Add in coconut flour and arrowroot starch and mix. Lastly, add in apple cider vinegar and mix again until the dough holds together and doesn't stick to the bowl. (Add a pinch of extra coconut flour if it's too sticky.)
  6. Separate dough into 12 round balls and then flatten each one slightly on the prepared baking sheet. With your thumb or the edge of spoon, make an indent in the center of each cookie.
  7. Bake for 12 minutes, then let cool while you make the frosting.
  8. In a small bowl, stir melted coconut butter and raw honey together, then add in 1-2 drops of peppermint oil and stir.
  9. Once cookies are cooled, drop teaspoons of the frosting in the center of each cookie. Enjoy!
Notes
~Feel free to sub cocoa powder for the carob, but since cocoa isn't as naturally sweet, you may need to add extra coconut sugar or honey to the dough.
~If the frosting is too runny, put in the fridge or freezer to firm up a little. If it's too firm, add a ¼ teaspoon of melted coconut oil.
~Store covered at room temp or in the fridge. If not using right away, cover and freeze.

3.5.3226

**The post contains affiliate links to which I may receive compensation if an item is purchased.  Please know that I only write about products I love and am passionate about!  For more info, read my disclosure.**

Share this:

  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: AIP, All Recipes, Dessert Tagged With: AIP, baking, carob, chocolate, christmas, coconut butter, cookies, dairy-free, egg-free, gluten-free, holiday, nightshade-free, nut-free, paleo, peppermint, soy-free, thumbprints

Previous Post: « AIP Thanksgiving Stuffing (Paleo)
Next Post: AIP Peppermint Hot Cocoa (Paleo) + Waiting Well »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Julie Woodside says

    December 15, 2020 at 12:29 am

    Oh dear,,, the sentence I needed ends on a cliff hanger — if I don’t have peppermint oil, I should use peppermint extract “and about 1/4 teaspoon or so ” of what?! Please advise! I was just about to make these, but need tomake exactly that sub. Thanks!

    Reply
    • Joanna says

      December 15, 2020 at 9:39 am

      Hi Julie,
      I think you were confused by my phrasing, but I was trying to say you can substitute “1/4 teaspoon or so” of peppermint extract in place of the food grade peppermint oil. I haven’t made them with peppermint extract so this is an approximation and you might need to add more if you want a stronger mint flavor. Happy baking!

      Reply
  2. Christina P. says

    March 15, 2021 at 5:36 pm

    I know it isn’t Christmas, but as someone who’s new and struggling to find a treat now and then on the AIP diet, I made these out of season. The only thing I changed was adding about 1 tbsp maple syrup to the cookie mix and once again maple syrup (instead of honey) with the coconut butter “frosting” because I didn’t have any peppermint extract at the time. These were SO GOOD. SO GOOD. I feel like I am cheating. Bonus, I thought the maple syrup took the aftertaste of the carob out that I sometimes struggle to get over. I will be making these many times, for sure.

    I also made the ginger cookies from your site the other day, and I just have to add that you have the cookie texture DOWN. They have both been so soft and chewy. Completely satisfying. I can’t wait to find more things on your site to try!

    Reply
    • Joanna says

      March 16, 2021 at 9:40 am

      Christina, thank you so much for the compliments and for sharing your experience with my recipes! Your words make my heart happy! 🥰 It’s so nice we can still enjoy delicious treats, even on the AIP diet! All the best to you in your health journey!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Rate this recipe:  

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Hi! Welcome to Fed and Fulfilled!

I'm Joanna, a passionate foodie and developer of gluten-free, Paleo, & AIP recipes. I hope my blog will help to feed your body and fulfill your soul! Read More…

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Search Fed and Fulfilled

Never Miss a Post!

Sign up to receive news, updates, and recipes from Fed and Fulfilled!

Categories

Archives

Most Popular Posts

Egg-Free Breakfast Casserole (AIP, Paleo)
Turkey Apple Breakfast Hash (AIP)
Frosted Cut-Out Sugar Cookies (AIP, Paleo, Vegan)
Citrus Fennel Salad with Grapefruit Vinaigrette (AIP)
Paleo Triple Berry Trifle (AIP)
Easy Paleo Drop Biscuits (AIP)

Follow Fed and Fulfilled on Pinterest!

Footer

Connect with Me

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Never Miss a Post!

Sign up to receive the latest news, updates, posts, and recipes from Fed and Fulfilled!

Search Fed and Fulfilled

COPYRIGHT

At Fed and Fulfilled, we work hard to create original, unique content. We appreciate your discretion when sharing any of our property, including links, pages, recipes, and photos. If you are using more than 2 of our photos and/or copying more than 2 lines of text, please contact Fed and Fulfilled and receive consent before publishing. Photos or recipes used must link back to the original post on our site and must reference Fed and Fulfilled in your post. Thank you!

Copyright © 2025 · Foodie Pro Theme by Shay Bocks · Built on the Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress